AFRID vs Disordered Eating

Share

Erica Nutritionist
Erica Kessler

June 2, 2025

ARFID vs. Picky Eating: How to Tell the Difference & When to Get Help

What Is ARFID?

If you’ve ever experienced intense discomfort, anxiety, or aversions around food, it’s possible you could be dealing with Avoidant Restrictive Food Intake Disorder, or ARFID. Avoidant Restrictive Food Intake Disorder is an eating disorder that is not focused on weight, body shape, and doesn’t usually involve the desire to lose weight.

ARFID is an eating disorder where an individual avoids certain foods or eats very little for other reasons.

Individuals with ARFID might have a fear of choking, vomiting, or getting physically sick from eating. They may have sensory processing issues and struggle with sensitivity to the taste, texture, smell or physical appearance of certain foods. They may have little to no interest in food or eating at all. For some, eating can bring pleasure and comfort, which is not the case for those with ARFID.

Individuals with ARFID may not feel hunger cues in the same way, or they might find the act of eating overwhelming or uncomfortable.

What Is “Normal” Picky Eating?

Children are typically introduced to solid foods at around 6 months of age, and from that point on, they begin to explore a wide variety of tastes, textures, and smells.

During the early childhood years, roughly ages 1 to 5, children are still learning what they like and don’t like, and their food preferences can change frequently as a normal part of their development. Picky eating is common and expected in early childhood. It’s normal for children this age to:

  • Favor certain foods over others. This could be for their textures, temperatures, color, or shape
  • Have unpredictable eating habits. A food they love one day might be completely refused the next
  • Be hesitant to try new foods. This is a behavior called neophobia, which commonly occurs between the ages of 2 and 6.
  • Stick to what they know. They avoid certain foods that may smell, look, or taste different.

Picky behaviors are usually temporary and are a part of early development. They often happen as young children learn to explore their surroundings and begin asserting independence by making their own choices.

Most kids outgrow picky eating as they get older and are more in tune with their food preferences. As their taste buds develop and they gain more experience with a variety of flavors and textures, they tend to feel more comfortable and curious about trying new foods.

Over time, this increased exposure helps them better understand their own food preferences and makes mealtimes less stressful for kids and parents.

ARFID vs. Picky Eating: Key Differences

Impact on Physical Health

ARFID often leads to nutritional deficiencies, weight loss, or stunted growth—picky eating rarely does.

Typical picky eating is usually mild and doesn’t cause serious health problems. ARFID is more extreme, involving a much more severe restriction of food intake that can lead to major physical health impacts.

Children diagnosed with ARFID may eat so little or avoid so many foods that their bodies don’t get the nutrients they need to function optimally. As a result, ARFID can lead to:

  • Vitamin and mineral deficiencies
  • Low energy levels and weakened immune response
  • Significant weight loss or trouble gaining weight
  • Falling off their growth curve or delayed growth and development in children

In contrast, picky eaters usually maintain adequate nutrition to sustain healthy growth and development. Their food preferences also tend to expand and become more inclusive with age.

Emotional Distress & Social Avoidance

ARFID can have significant impacts on daily life beyond just eating habits. It often leads to severe anxiety around eating, turning meals into a source of stress. Individuals with ARFID may choose to avoid all social gatherings that include food to hide their fear, discomfort, or overall sensory issues.

For some, the smell, texture, or even presence of certain foods can trigger panic or distress. This sensitivity can lead to isolation from all social groups, making it difficult to participate in everyday activities and connect with others.

One common situation is a child with ARFID who avoids a friend’s birthday party because they’re anxious about the unfamiliar foods that will be served. The fear of trying something new or experiencing unpleasant sensory reactions can make the event feel overwhelming, so they choose to stay home instead, missing out on social connections and fun.

Duration & Severity

In the early stages of development, it should be expected for children to go through phases of food refusals or picky eating. However, if the avoidance and fear become more severe over time and don’t improve with age, repeated exposure, or encouragement, it may need further attention, as atypical behaviors do.

As time passes, ongoing restrictive eating that leads to noticeable weight changes, poor growth, nutritional deficiencies, recurrent avoidance of meals, and social gatherings may suggest the presence of ARFID. Unlike picky eating that improves with repeated exposures, time, and support, ARFID symptoms can persist and worsen without professional help. That’s why it’s essential for individuals to address the diagnosis by seeking evaluation and treatment.

Early recognition and intervention can make a significant difference in managing ARFID. With the support of a specialized treatment team, children and adults can work toward overcoming their fears and expanding their diets in a safe, gradual way.

The goal is not just to improve nutrition but also to reduce anxiety around food and restore a sense of normalcy to mealtimes and social interactions.

Signs It May Be Time to Seek Help

  • Eating fewer than 10 foods
  • Avoiding entire food groups
  • Weight loss or poor growth
  • Intense anxiety around meals
  • Meals are turning into a daily struggle

If you or your child is experiencing ongoing challenges with eating, here are some signs that it may be time to seek professional support:

  • Eating fewer than 10 foods regularly
  • Avoiding entire food groups (e.g., no carbohydrates, no added sugar, no green foods)
  • Weight loss, poor weight gain, or slowed growth
  • Intense anxiety, fear, or distress around meals
  • Mealtimes are becoming a daily struggle filled with stress, avoidance, and conflict
  • Avoiding social events that involve food
  • Strong sensory reactions to textures, smells, or aesthetics of food
  • No improvement over time, even after repeated exposures and support

If any of these signs feel familiar to you or a loved one, it may suggest something more serious than typical picky eating, possibly ARFID. Reaching out for professional help can be an important step toward better understanding the experience of living with ARFID and learning how to support recovery effectively.

What Causes ARFID?

ARFID can develop from a range of underlying factors, and it’s important to recognize that it is not a choice and is not a result of bad parenting.

Several factors may contribute to its development, including:

  • Sensory sensitivities: This includes being sensitive to the way a food looks, smells, tastes, or is packaged. This is especially common among individuals with autism spectrum disorder or sensory processing disorders.
  • Lack of appetite or lack of hunger cues: Some people with ARFID may rarely feel physical hunger or be able to identify hunger cues, have very little to no interest in food, often making eating feel uncomfortable and unpleasant for others.
  • Traumatic food-related experiences: This includes incidents such as choking, vomiting, or severe gastrointestinal distress, which can cause a strong fear around food.

It’s essential to emphasize that ARFID is not a choice, not a phase, and not the result of bad parenting. It’s a very complex mental health condition that may come with behavioral disturbances and is often misunderstood, misdiagnosed, and mistreated.

Individuals who are diagnosed with ARFID require compassion, support, and understanding in order to begin healing.

How ARFID Is Treated

Treatment for ARFID often involves a multidisciplinary approach, including a team of professionals working together to support the individual’s physical and emotional well-being. This team may include, but is not limited to:

  • Registered Dietitians, who focus on ensuring that nutritional needs are met for growth parameters and development by expanding food variety in a safe, gradual way.
  • Eating Disorder Therapists, who address the underlying anxiety, past negative experiences with food, or emotional factors that may contribute to recurrent avoidance.
  • Occupational Therapists, who can assist with addressing sensory sensitivities or motor challenges affecting eating.

Treatment begins with building trust with providers and creating a safe space to discuss fear foods. This often involves having patience with guided exposures to new foods. There is no set timeline as everyone moves at their own pace.

Because ARFID affects everyone differently, individualized care is key. There is no single “right” path to take as progress happens through patience, support, and a personalized plan tailored to each person’s unique needs.

How One Nutrition Group Supports ARFID & Picky Eating

At One Nutrition Group, we understand how overwhelming and emotional it can be when your child struggles with food. That’s why we offer individualized care that meets each child exactly where they are, with empathy and patience guiding them through every step.

We believe in collaboration, not just within our own team, but alongside other providers such as therapists, doctors, occupational therapists, and others. Together, we build a support system that helps the child feel safe, heard, and understood.

Our philosophy is that healing begins with feeling safe. That’s why there’s no pressure, no forcing, and never any shame. We meet each child where they are, with patience and understanding, without rushing or pushing.

Instead of focusing on what they “should” be eating, we create a calm, trusting space where small, meaningful steps are celebrated. Over time, those steps build real progress because when a child feels supported, lasting change becomes possible.

If you’re a parent reading this, this is not your fault. ARFID is not caused by something you did or didn’t do. Your love, effort, and support always count, even on the hard days. With the right treatment team, progress can happen, and we’re here to support you every step of the way.

Final Thoughts: Understanding First, Then Support

If you’re still unsure whether your child is dealing with ARFID or just picky eating, that’s okay. The differences can be hard to spot during early childhood. What truly matters is that you’re taking the time to learn, comprehend the challenges, and access support.

Having a treatment team to support you and your child is a powerful, supportive way to begin healing their relationship with food, and that’s something to be proud of.

Don’t wait to get the support your family deserves. At One Nutrition Group, our experienced team of dietitians specializes in working with children and families facing feeding challenges like ARFID and picky eating.

We offer compassionate, evidence-based nutrition care to meet your child’s nutritional needs and help them heal their relationship with food. Reach out to One Nutrition Group today to learn more about our services and start your family’s journey toward healing.